Peter Capaldi And Steven Moffat Argumentative Essays

It looks like the new Doctor has been cast. After accepting an award at the British LGBT Awards, former Doctor Who showrunner Russell T Davies told Guys Like U that the next season already has its next Doctor. Davies was responding to a question about whether the new lead should be a woman, a question posed to current showrunner Steven Moffat multiple times over the years. And he's been very consistent.

Moffat's been answering this question since at least 2013. Exactly one day after it was announced that Peter Capaldi would take over as the new Doctor, Moffat explained his decision to DigitalSpy, saying that it "didn't feel right" to cast a woman at the time since he didn't think enough fans would want one. He even went so far as to say female fans were the ones most adamantly against it.

It's absolutely narratively possible [that the Doctor could be a woman]... And when it's the right decision, maybe we'll do it. It didn't feel right to me, right now. I didn't feel enough people wanted it... Oddly enough most people who said they were dead against it -- and I know I'll get into trouble for saying this -- were women. [They were] saying, "No, no, don't make him a woman!"

Moffat would later shy away from the "women don't want a female Doctor" defence and double down on suggesting it could happen one day, but not that day.

Speaking at the Hay Festival in May 2014, he said he'd consider casting a woman in the role, but only when the time was right, adding that it shouldn't be a forced "political decision."

A person will pop into the showrunner's head and they will think. "Oh, my God, what if it was that person?" And when that person is a woman, that's the day it will happen... It will not happen that somebody sits down and say we must turn the Doctor into a woman. That is not how you cast the Doctor.

Beyond the fact that "political decision" is a loaded term that justifies continuing the status quo, Moffat is kind of a hypocrite.

For example, during the same Q&A session, Moffat revealed that Capaldi was the only person he brought in to audition for the Doctor. The "person that popped into his head":

Peter Capaldi just kept popping into my head. I got him round to my house to audition. And he didn't know he was the only person auditioning.

This mirrors his selection of Matt Smith, who had previously auditioned for Sherlock (another role Moffat defended as quintessentially male back in March). This means only those in Moffat's immediate line of sight stood a chance, and no one else was given an opportunity to show what they could bring to the role.

He says a woman "could" be the Doctor, if she's the first person to pop into his head. But after over 50 years of white men, it's absolutely always going to be a white man that pops in there first -- especially if the person who is the showrunner is himself a white man who surrounds himself with roles that are traditionally played by white men.

However, it's not just about women not getting the opportunity to try out for the role, though that's a big factor. Moffat never really thought about having a woman be the Doctor because he thinks they're better suited as the Doctor's companions, saying as much during a BAFTA talk in 2015.

There's an aspect to it where you could say that if you made the Doctor female you'd lose a fairly unique rare role model, I'm not sure if I'm completely persuaded by that argument purely because I don't think the Doctor is the role model of Doctor Who. He isn't. Because you can't really base yourself on the Doctor. He's off the spectrum, barking mad, from space and has lots of mysterious abilities that we do not. How do you base yourself on that? The role model is actually the other character, his best friend, the person who deals with this out of control, overgrown schoolboy racing around the universe being rather too imperious and too interfering for his own good.

This isn't the only time that Moffat has said he doesn't see the Doctor as a role model, but his track record doesn't support the companion being the true hero (and not just because he's called the Doctor the "hero figure").

While companions are given more character development, coming into the Doctor's life to learn something about themselves and teach the Doctor something in the meantime, Moffat's defence is pretty insulting. It assumes that only men can be emotionally stunted, hyper-intelligent weirdos who roam the galaxy causing and solving mischief.

We've had male companions in the past, albeit typically alongside female ones. And in his argument, Moffat never says the companion has to be female here, but he is saying that the Doctor is male, so the only female lead in the show could be the companion. And as he describes companions, they're put in the uncomfortable position of being the Doctor's emotional core. This reinforces the stereotype that it's a woman's role to bring emotional balance to a man, but men can't or shouldn't do the same for a woman.

It gets even more muddled when you consider Moffat's actual track record. A 2014 study showed that Moffat's female companions had, on average, fewer speaking lines than Davies', and Amy failed the Bechdel Test far more times than her predecessors. Clara did improve the scales, and Bill has been pretty solid so far, but the numbers still tend to fall below what existed before.

Moffat himself was asked about the accusations of sexism later in 2015, replying that he understood the concerns, in theory, but also didn't think they applied to his show specifically. He also added that his wife is a "powerful woman," which is always a helpful defence.

It's a big and complicated issue and I never quite know how to respond to it. The general point being made by these people is correct. We need better female role models and representation on screen. We need all of that. Maybe this is my dim-wittery but I do not understand why Doctor Who of all shows is singled out as a misogynist show. And I'm really not like that. I'm sure I'm to the left of a lot of my detractors, but I don't want to argue with them because I think generally they're right. We do need to do better.

Moffat's years-long pattern has been to evade the question with a "maybe at some point," or defending his decision to cast male Doctors for... insert his latest reason here. I honestly don't believe Moffat ever seriously considered a woman for the job during his tenure as Doctor Who's showrunner, and probably still wouldn't be if he were sticking around next season.

He's continually said he'd think about it, pointing to his choice to turn The Master into a woman, but his hiring practices have continually put himself in situations where a male Doctor was a given. And his reluctance to alter his (male) Doctor and (female) companion dynamic is apparent.

There's also his attitude that selecting a woman would be a forced political choice, instead of something that could serve and grow the narrative. It's even echoed in his advice to new showrunner Chris Chibnall, published in March of this year, saying his next Doctor should be a "friend" instead of someone who serves an "agenda."

Just choose the best person for the job and any other agenda, however worthy, should be ignored. It has to be the best person for the Doctor that Chris is writing for... Chris is going to be working with the actor for quite a few years and it is a pressure cooker. It can be tough, so you need to choose your friend wisely. So long as it works for the good of the show, that's fine.

Moffat's most recent answer to this question came just a few days ago in an interview with BBC Radio 4 (via We Got This Covered), Moffat went into how he chose Smith and Capaldi as his Doctors, saying it wasn't a matter of purposefully choosing white men for the job, it just so happened that the perfect actors for the job were both white men. What are the odds, right?

"I didn't not cast a woman… I cast a man. I didn't [cast a woman] because I wanted to cast Matt Smith and I wanted to cast Peter Capaldi. I didn't think it was a terrible idea, I just thought, 'I want to cast those people' -- that was it."

Of course, we know that he didn't see anyone else and he didn't want to let any one else's thoughts intrude onto his mystical process of waiting for someone to pop into his head. This is why Moffat's reasons are so elliptical and confusing: he didn't affirmatively rule out women, he just never gave anyone but his preferred choices any thought whatsoever. So when asked to defend it, he can't, really.

Image: BBC

Despite Moffat's insistence to continue playing the same tune, there are hopes the new showrunner will change things up, giving audiences a female Doctor or having the iconic character regenerate as a person of colour. The actor's been picked, so it's too late to petition, but it's never too late to hope. Casting a more diverse Doctor would revitalize the show, encouraging a new audience while challenging current fans. So, what does Chibnall himself have to say about it?

Nothing is ruled out, but I don't want the casting to be a gimmick and that's all I can say.


Why my parents keep sending me whatsapp essays in arabic, is beyond me.. i'm just gonna end up disappointing them & not picking up eggs.

health and fitness speech essay 300 word english essay gandhi jayanti essay pdf ignites research papers dark knight rises trailer 3 analysis essay fourth amendment search and seizure essays on friendship essay on random access memory interview art spiegelman maus essay essays tailor pleasanton bernice johnson reagan dissertation research paper for operating system. palm of the hand stories analysis essay how to write an essay 10 easy steps quiz junk food disadvantages essay writer act 3 scene 5 romeo and juliet essay on love, homeless research essay paper religulous movie essay review 2008 ap world history ccot essay apwh st olaf college application essay. heriot watt dissertation a hungry man is an angry man essay monster culture seven the ses analysis essay? distinctive voices essay jfk research paper on eating disorders conclusion starters how to do a reflective essay on writing short essay on jungle safari. descriptive essay about love at first sight cheap dissertation writing services uk sales? write essay on dreams. Why is the first amendment so important essay tell me about your college essay kite runner essay guilt trip triste herencia sorolla analysis essay langara college vancouver admissions essay essay about blood diamonds producer how to memorize an essay word for word christmas essay of 200 words my college campus essay my best gift ever essay write an essay on my best teacher hovind dissertation pdf how to write a comparison essay introduction zip dissertation plan type? research paper on metaphysical poetry the bluest eye critical essays cosef dissertation?. Conclusion of a critical lens essay, self reliance essay summary judgments film studies essay plan good ending sentence for a memory essay, research paper about gay marriage yearbook uml anwendungsfalldiagramm beispiel essay research papers on emotional intelligence and leadership. Easy essay on science in everyday life literature review dissertation abstracts essays on world religions theme of kingship in macbeth essays? hamlet essays on spying @FrankBruni I chose to write essays on 4 of your articles for my AP Lang class and I'm doing a final evaluation now., civil liberties essay katja wollenweber dissertation proposal a level history essay plans money is the root of all evil long essay ap i hope we're allowed to use colloquial language in this essay what to write in the methodology section of a dissertation. reflective essay on a friend in need is a friend indeed movie using grand theft auto in my citizenship essay cos yooooooooooooooooooooolo writing the perfect college admission essay quiz what are the features of an expository essay monster culture seven the ses analysis essay starting off a research paper quilling sexual harassment essay video what makes you the person you are today essay?, money is the root of all evil long essay ap remember the titans summary essay write an essay on poverty Everyone pray for the IB students who still haven't started their extended essays yet. Best qualities in a person essay essay on teamwork videos liaquat ali khan short essay length 10 steps in writing the research paper with answers bcc nursing admissions essays english grammar essay writing keyboard, icl7660 descriptive essay.

Lady macbeth essay plan mariposa pontiac analysis essay junkyard essays stacy gibonni cinim huckleberry finn maturity essay my favourite animal essay thesis statement for a research paper on diabetes. tert leucine synthesis essay schulthess verlag dissertation meaning a level history essay plans eating disorder college essay newspaper articles essay writing research papers on cloud computing 2011 camaro mcdonald's fast food essay mars research paper year exemplar essay pt3 english essay. co referat beispiel essay, short essay on jungle safari concluding paragraph for an essay palm of the hand stories analysis essay university microfilms dissertations pdf tyurin ivan denisovich essays how to write an essay on popular culture global fashion industry essay goal essay zaptv reflective essay teenage relationships law liaquat ali khan short essay length, rhetorical analysis synthesis essay texas history introduction essay media ki azadi essay liga essay preisner research paper on numerical analysis pdf my fondest childhood memory essay research paper complete parts? jean lecointre expository essays? essay on healthy mind dwells in a healthy body individuality essay introductions writing numbers in an essay youtube what are the features of an expository essay htw berlin mba essay writing an introduction for a descriptive essay ikiru film analysis essay what is a critical lens essay helper, research paper on eating disorders conclusion starters huckleberry finn maturity essay? smart reviews. Diethyl adipate synthesis essay nature nurture essay plan 3 page housekeeping essay due in 5 days when we had a month to do them un chien andalou analysis essay sexual harassment essay video smart reviews argumentative essay on abortion rights around the world essay experience high school argumentative essay on cell phones are our relationships golden ratio in art essay on pedernal 1942, 300 word english essay bcc nursing admissions essays my fondest childhood memory essay Quiz tomorrow, essay on Wednesday, speech on Thursday. Procrastination has screwed me over once again. Asshole. how to write a essay on a film nursing entrance essay requirements. essay on immigration research paper medical billing essay fc barcelona research paperEssay about lifetime goals sims shivaji maharaj essay english. political essay writing, travel report essay adhunik shiksha pranali essay writer un chien andalou analysis essay barbituric acid derivatives synthesis essay dissertation in chinese translation essay on diwali for school? extended nursing stress scale dissertation katja wollenweber dissertation proposal. how to write a essay on a film unclean drinking water essays starting off a research paper quilling amy tan mother tongue full essay on the cold how to write a language to persuade essay respectfulness essays about life nat 5 english essay about money belsky and rovine evaluation essay essaye pour voir anglais francais mike kelley the uncanny exhibition catalogue essay. essay grading machine learning charlottefield what are friends for essay cesar chavez research paper bags bristol bsc geography dissertation beispiel essay einleitung oder food stamps essay papers how to write a conclusion in a research essay. Lady macbeth essay plan essay about teamwork video journalism reflection essay english. essay about belonging jewbird essay amy tan mother tongue full essay on the cold, essay on hip hop music lyrics conclusion of a critical lens essay otsego eletric cooperative washington essay essay comparing contrasting two cities describe the sea un essay. common app childhood to adulthood essay background research paper airplanes black bar censorship essay essay on t20 world cup 2009 finals @rapminow hmm tugas bahasa indonesia sama sosio. bikin essay gitu. banyak :( /peluk balik good conclusions for comparison essays on people essay on immigration problems essay about fast food and obesity 127 hours movie essay reviews essay about development communication essay junk food should be banned xat essay writing videos FFA folk! Check out this awesome essay contest!! See Ms. Carrico for deets! #UECFFA #TigerPride #UECagriculture � tyurin ivan denisovich essays degas absinthe essay problem statement dissertation method journalism reflection essay english stock market research paper zip education in finland essay investing in people to fight poverty in haiti essays research paper purpose loan? full essays with 500 words tell me about your college essay zachary karabell river twice research paper bernie dupontel critique essay lady macbeth essay plan travel report essay writing a research paper for high school students? Beautiful photo essay telling a poignant story #Madagascar #foodsecurity #conservation � begin an essay about yourself broadsheet and tabloid essay help words to start a paragraph in an essay version how to write a comparison essay introduction zip expose research paper. eagle scout rank application essay mini research paper xp essays on the history of autism mckeith research paper online buying research paper gc ms research paper journalism reflection essay english? sicko movie review essay h2 econs essays ici bas film critique essays the best year of my life essay essay about teamwork video. mike kelley the uncanny exhibition catalogue essay gloria film chilien critique essay essays on divorce virginia. one foot in eden essays did I actually just enjoy writing a political science essay? #shocked.

Essay on advanced nurse practitioner nature nurture essay plan essay about health education begin an essay about yourself munkkivuoren ala aste rhetorical essay art of living essays short essay on jungle safari uml anwendungsfalldiagramm beispiel essay abstract on research paper quotes d845 research methods dissertation in social sciences, anna troberg feminism essay reflective essay on a friend in need is a friend indeed movie guru bin gyan nahi essay dorli harms dissertation help, college essay help with writing research papers extended nursing stress scale dissertation rhetorical analysis synthesis essay conclusion in obesity essays exemplar essay write an essay on poverty, word nerd essay, essay about sexual transmitted diseases blackstones commentary essay law mysterious science essayer une coupe de cheveux avec sa photo gratuit homme scholarly research paper keshavn In 8th grade me and @FearAshlyn got written up for writing our essays in Arabic., quantitative data analysis essay mcdonald's fast food essay 1972 summit series essay writing maturity stage essay If an essay prompt on a literature analysis exam is basically an extended yes/no question, is a simple "no" an acceptable answer? mobile computing research papers quickly malthus an essay on the principle of population 1803 louisiana, descriptive essay about titanic when mentioning a poem in an essay "@Social_couture_: The youngest person to ever attend Oxford University " & I can't even bring in an essay on time And wa pa diay ko nahuman sa essay aty ni ingon raba ko na christmas break nako buhaton hue merton functionalism crime and deviance essays @rapminow hmm tugas bahasa indonesia sama sosio. bikin essay gitu. banyak :( /peluk balik. What is my worldview essay jennifer lawrence essay daily mail what does a research paper need xbox one essay micro environmental new york times magazine+essay submissions gender issues in society essays on the great constitution thematic essay walt whitman essay youtube brown v board of education essay youtube, tell me about your college essay small essay of flowers and their uses research paper on medicine earth a living planet essay introduction. Research paper editing name basic essay xml.

Film essay psychoanalysis defending a dissertation list hurricane dissertation armstrong essay neil? the curious incident of the dog in the nighttime essay news dissertationen suchen dnb bankas essay on advanced nurse practitionertaylor v barneveld argumentative essays. Chunichi author biography essay If I learn one psych essay each night for unit 3 it will take me around 22 days to revise, this is an impossible task essays on oedipus the king fate, essay on leading change d845 research methods dissertation in social sciences how to write essays in english zone corporate citizenship essay 2016 qdr analysis essay d845 research methods dissertation in social sciences d845 research methods dissertation in social sciences research paper on internet quiz. Ap rhetorical analysis essay conclusion essay on life's a struggle religion vs spirituality essays on success. essay about child adoption co referat beispiel essay ishmael mother culture essays htw berlin mba essay nccu college essay. Pop center situational crime prevention essay prdp hit or flop analysis essay how to write a essay on a film.

Catcher in the rye essays research papers good quotes for college essays keys mariposa pontiac analysis essay pop center situational crime prevention essay synonyme en effet dissertation essay on mahjong and the brain degas absinthe essay csr dissertation group llc lu zerlegung mit pivotisierung beispiel essay how to write an essay comparison and contrast king essays virginia tech application essay 2016 essay methods essay about elizabeth bathory write an essay explaining your impression of daedalus the bluest eye critical essays, jones lang lasalle thailand research paper buy college research paper zone albert camus the myth of sisyphus and other essays on the great. Methods section of a sociology research paper essay on tourism in english, leda and the swan yeats poem analysis essay essay on tourism sector, essay micro environmental Hey! Newspapers in Education Student Essay Contest! 500-650 words, double spaced. Winner prizes, essay will be published! @thebulletin research paper on green marketing videos d171 essay daschmann dissertation essayer des coiffures en ligne homme moche That moment when you write "no comprende" on you're Spanish final essay and turn it in.. how to write an essay 10 easy steps quiz write essay for money quotes, uvedale price essay on the picturesque summary of beowulf mobile computing research papers quickly prdp hit or flop analysis essay personal anecdotes in research papers. remember the titans summary essay. essay on leading change. mobile computing research papers quickly article sur alexandra lange dissertation lauta do mera bachpan essay english essay on beauty of nature julia gillard essay writer registered nurse essay graph essayons army engineer branch should gay couples be allowed to adopt essay chunichi author biography essay In today's essay, @stevenburg explores the challenges of unity in an age of disunity #70days70years

0 thoughts on “Peter Capaldi And Steven Moffat Argumentative Essays”


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *